Is AFSIA or STAG a better dividend investment in 2026?

AFSIA currently yields 12.59% with a 5% 5-year dividend growth rate. STAG yields 3.44% with 1% growth. The better choice depends on your goal: AFSIA offers higher current income.

What is the dividend yield difference between AFSIA and STAG?

AFSIA has a forward dividend yield of 12.59% ($1.69/share annually). STAG yields 3.44% ($1.24/share annually). The yield gap is 9.15 percentage points.

Home › Compare › AFSIA vs STAG

AFSIA vs STAG: Dividend Comparison 2026

AFSIA yields 12.59% · STAG yields 3.44%● Live data

vsPost on X →

After 10 years · $10,000 invested · DRIP enabled

🏆 AFSIA wins by $3.6K in total portfolio value

INVESTMENT

TIME HORIZON10 years

AFSIA

● Live price

12.59%

Share price

$13.40

Annual div

$1.69

5Y div CAGR

-50%

Payout ratio

50%

After 10 yrs · $10,000 · DRIP

Portfolio value

$21.9K

Annual income

$1.37

Full AFSIA calculator →

STAG

STAG Industrial Inc.

● Live price

3.44%

Share price

$36.06

Annual div

$1.24

5Y div CAGR

0.3%

Payout ratio

50%

After 10 yrs · $10,000 · DRIP

Portfolio value

$18.3K

Annual income

$462.70

Full STAG calculator →

Portfolio growth — AFSIA vs STAG

📍 AFSIA pulled ahead of the other in Year 1

Annual dividend income

🛡️

Recession Test — Did They Cut Dividends?

How each stock treated shareholders during the 3 biggest crises of the last 20 years

Crisis Period	AFSIA	STAG
2008–2009 GFC	— No data	— No data
2020 Q1–Q2 COVID	— No data	— No data
2022 Q4 Rate Hike	— No data	— No data

Based on dividend payment history. "Increased" = dividend grew during crisis. "Maintained" = held within 3%. "Cut" = reduced by more than 3%.

📅

Dividend Calendar Overlap

Combined, AFSIA + STAG cover 0 of 12 months — good coverage

Jan

—

Feb

—

Mar

—

Apr

—

May

—

Jun

—

Jul

—

Aug

—

Sep

—

Oct

—

Nov

—

Dec

—

AFSIA pays

STAG pays

Both pay

Neither

💰

Tax Bracket Optimizer

Which stock is actually better after tax? Adjust your rate to find out.

AFSIA

Annual income on $10K today (after 15% tax)

$1,070.44/yr

After 10yr DRIP, annual income (after tax)

$1.16/yr

STAG

Annual income on $10K today (after 15% tax)

$292.69/yr

After 10yr DRIP, annual income (after tax)

$393.29/yr

At 15% tax rate, STAG beats the other by $392.13/year in after-tax income after 10 years on $10,000

⚖️

Lazy Portfolio Split Optimizer

What's the optimal mix of AFSIA + STAG for your $10,000?

AFSIA: 50%STAG: 50%

100% STAG50/50100% AFSIA

Portfolio after 10yr

$20.1K

Annual income

$232.04/yr

Blended yield

1.15%

📊

Analyst Conviction Gap

Where Wall Street is most bullish on STAG right now

AFSIA

No analyst data

Altman Z

0.8

Piotroski

4/9

STAG

Analyst Ratings

Buy

Hold

Sell

Consensus: Buy

Price Target

$45.00

+24.8% upside vs current

Range: $39.00 — $59.00

Altman Z

1.2

Piotroski

5/9

Analyst ratings via FMP. Altman Z-Score: >3.0 safe, 1.81–3.0 grey zone, <1.81 distress. Piotroski: 7–9 strong, 0–3 weak.

🏛️

Copy Congress — What Are Politicians Buying?

Senate & House STOCK Act disclosures (last 90 days)

AFSIA buys

STAG buys

No recent congressional trades found for AFSIA or STAG in the last 90 days.

STOCK Act mandates disclosure within 45 days of transaction. Data via FMP.Full tracker →

MetricAFSIASTAG

Forward yield	12.59% ✓	3.44%
Annual dividend / share	$1.69 ✓	$1.24
Payout ratio	50%	50%
1-year div growth	0%	0%
5-year div CAGR	-50%	0.3% ✓
Portfolio after 10y	$21.9K ✓	$18.3K
Annual income after 10y	$1.37	$462.70 ✓
Total dividends collected	$1.3K	$4.0K ✓
Payment frequency	quarterly	monthly
Sector	Stock	REIT

Year-by-year: AFSIA vs STAG ($10,000, DRIP)

Year	AFSIA Portfolio	AFSIA Income/yr	STAG Portfolio	STAG Income/yr	Gap
1← crossover	$11,330	$629.67	$10,665	$345.38	+$665.00 → AFSIA
2	$12,456	$333.36	$11,365	$358.01	+$1.1K → AFSIA
3	$13,499	$171.27	$12,099	$370.76	+$1.4K → AFSIA
4	$14,531	$86.73	$12,870	$383.63	+$1.7K → AFSIA
5	$15,592	$43.63	$13,678	$396.60	+$1.9K → AFSIA
6	$16,705	$21.87	$14,526	$409.67	+$2.2K → AFSIA
7	$17,885	$10.95	$15,413	$422.82	+$2.5K → AFSIA
8	$19,143	$5.48	$16,343	$436.05	+$2.8K → AFSIA
9	$20,486	$2.74	$17,315	$449.35	+$3.2K → AFSIA
10	$21,921	$1.37	$18,332	$462.70	+$3.6K → AFSIA

AFSIA vs STAG: Complete Analysis 2026

AFSIA — Stock

AmTrust Financial Services, Inc. operates as a property and casualty company. It offers automobile, commercial auto liability, liability, products liability, marine, inland marine, multi-peril, commercial multiple peril (liability portion), workers' compensation, and other property and casualty insurance. It was founded in 1998 and is headquartered in New York, New York.

Full AFSIA Calculator →

STAG — REIT

STAG Industrial, Inc. (NYSE: STAG) is a real estate investment trust focused on the acquisition and operation of single-tenant, industrial properties throughout the United States. By targeting this type of property, STAG has developed an investment strategy that helps investors find a powerful balance of income plus growth.

Full STAG Calculator →

📬

Get this AFSIA vs STAG comparison by email

Save your analysis + weekly dividend insights. Free forever.

More comparisons

AFSIA vs SCHD AFSIA vs JEPI AFSIA vs O AFSIA vs KO AFSIA vs MAIN AFSIA vs PLD AFSIA vs EQR AFSIA vs VICI

⚠️ Educational purposes only. Not financial advice. Congressional trades sourced from SEC STOCK Act filings via FMP. Past performance does not guarantee future results.