HomeCompareICE vs PAA

ICE vs PAA: Dividend Comparison 2026

ICE yields 1.25% · PAA yields 6.93%● Live data

vsPost on X →
After 10 years · $10,000 invested · DRIP enabled
🏆 PAA wins by $6.60M in total portfolio value
10 years
ICE
ICE
● Live price
1.25%
Share price
$156.94
Annual div
$1.96
5Y div CAGR
59.6%
Payout ratio
50%
After 10 yrs · $10,000 · DRIP
Portfolio value
$109.0K
Annual income
$44,156.55
Full ICE calculator →
PAA
PAA
● Live price
6.93%
Share price
$22.47
Annual div
$1.56
5Y div CAGR
57%
Payout ratio
50%
After 10 yrs · $10,000 · DRIP
Portfolio value
$6.71M
Annual income
$5,114,230.35
Full PAA calculator →

Portfolio growth — ICE vs PAA

📍 PAA pulled ahead of the other in Year 1

Annual dividend income

🛡️

Recession Test — Did They Cut Dividends?

How each stock treated shareholders during the 3 biggest crises of the last 20 years

Crisis PeriodICEPAA
2008–2009
GFC
— No data— No data
2020 Q1–Q2
COVID
— No data— No data
2022 Q4
Rate Hike
— No data— No data
Based on dividend payment history. "Increased" = dividend grew during crisis. "Maintained" = held within 3%. "Cut" = reduced by more than 3%.
📅

Dividend Calendar Overlap

Combined, ICE + PAA cover 0 of 12 monthsgood coverage

Jan
Feb
Mar
Apr
May
Jun
Jul
Aug
Sep
Oct
Nov
Dec
ICE pays
PAA pays
Both pay
Neither
💰

Tax Bracket Optimizer

Which stock is actually better after tax? Adjust your rate to find out.

ICE
Annual income on $10K today (after 15% tax)
$106.16/yr
After 10yr DRIP, annual income (after tax)
$37,533.07/yr
PAA
Annual income on $10K today (after 15% tax)
$589.17/yr
After 10yr DRIP, annual income (after tax)
$4,347,095.80/yr
At 15% tax rate, PAA beats the other by $4,309,562.73/year in after-tax income after 10 years on $10,000
⚖️

Lazy Portfolio Split Optimizer

What's the optimal mix of ICE + PAA for your $10,000?

ICE: 50%PAA: 50%
100% PAA50/50100% ICE
Portfolio after 10yr
$3.41M
Annual income
$2,579,193.45/yr
Blended yield
75.65%
📊

Analyst Conviction Gap

Where Wall Street is most bullish on ICE right now

ICE
Analyst Ratings
1
Strong
32
Buy
3
Hold
Consensus: Buy
Price Target
$192.86
+22.9% upside vs current
Range: $180.00 — $211.00
Altman Z
0.9
Piotroski
8/9
PAA
Analyst Ratings
1
Strong
23
Buy
16
Hold
2
Sell
Consensus: Buy
Price Target
$21.83
-2.8% upside vs current
Range: $17.00 — $25.00
Altman Z
2.3
Piotroski
5/9
Analyst ratings via FMP. Altman Z-Score: >3.0 safe, 1.81–3.0 grey zone, <1.81 distress. Piotroski: 7–9 strong, 0–3 weak.
🏛️

Copy Congress — What Are Politicians Buying?

Senate & House STOCK Act disclosures (last 90 days)

ICE buys
0
PAA buys
0
No recent congressional trades found for ICE or PAA in the last 90 days.
STOCK Act mandates disclosure within 45 days of transaction. Data via FMP.Full tracker →
MetricICEPAA
Forward yield1.25%6.93%
Annual dividend / share$1.96$1.56
Payout ratio50%50%
1-year div growth0%0%
5-year div CAGR59.6%57%
Portfolio after 10y$109.0K$6.71M
Annual income after 10y$44,156.55$5,114,230.35
Total dividends collected$83.1K$6.54M
Payment frequencyquarterlyquarterly
SectorFinancialsStock
Analyst consensusBuyBuy
Analyst price target$192.86$21.83

Year-by-year: ICE vs PAA ($10,000, DRIP)

YearICE PortfolioICE Income/yrPAA PortfolioPAA Income/yrGap
1← crossover$10,899$199.32$11,788$1,088.24$889.00PAA
2$11,986$324.04$14,496$1,882.30$2.5KPAA
3$13,357$531.54$18,907$3,396.22$5.5KPAA
4$15,175$883.50$26,730$6,499.60$11.6KPAA
5$17,735$1,497.24$42,084$13,482.87$24.3KPAA
6$21,586$2,609.94$76,177$31,147.09$54.6KPAA
7$27,836$4,738.36$164,235$82,725.90$136.4KPAA
8$38,898$9,113.83$437,430$261,698.43$398.5KPAA
9$60,617$18,996.59$1,490,777$1,022,727.50$1.43MPAA
10$109,017$44,156.55$6,709,362$5,114,230.35$6.60MPAA

ICE vs PAA: Complete Analysis 2026

ICEFinancials

Intercontinental Exchange, Inc., together with its subsidiaries, operates regulated exchanges, clearing houses, and listings venues for commodity, financial, fixed income, and equity markets in the United States, the United Kingdom, the European Union, Singapore, Israel, and Canada. It operates through three segments: Exchanges, Fixed Income and Data Services, and Mortgage Technology. The company operates marketplaces for listing, trading, and clearing an array of derivatives contracts and financial securities, such as commodities, interest rates, foreign exchange, and equities, as well as corporate and exchange-traded funds; trading venues, including 13 regulated exchanges and 6 clearing houses; and offers futures and options products for energy, agricultural and metals, financial, cash equities and equity, over-the-counter, and other markets, as well as listings and data and connectivity services. It also provides fixed income data and analytic, fixed income execution, CDS clearing, and other multi-asset class data and network services. In addition, the company offers proprietary and comprehensive mortgage origination platform, which serves residential mortgage loans; closing solutions that provides customers connectivity to the mortgage supply chain and facilitates the secure exchange of information; data and analytics services; and Data as a Service for lenders to access data and origination information. Intercontinental Exchange, Inc. was founded in 2000 and is headquartered in Atlanta, Georgia.

Full ICE Calculator →

PAAStock

Plains All American Pipeline, L.P., through its subsidiaries, engages in the pipeline transportation, terminalling, storage, and gathering of crude oil and natural gas liquids (NGL) in the United States and Canada. The company operates in two segments, Crude Oil and NGL. The Crude Oil segment offers gathering and transporting crude oil through pipelines, gathering systems, trucks, and at times on barges or railcars. This segment provides terminalling, storage, and other facilities-related services, as well as merchant activities. As of December 31, 2021, this segment owned and leased 18,300 miles of active crude oil transportation pipelines and gathering systems, as well as an additional 110 miles of pipelines that supports crude oil storage and terminalling facilities; 74 million barrels of commercial crude oil storage capacity; 38 million barrels of active, above-ground tank capacity; four marine facilities; a condensate processing facility; seven crude oil rail terminals and 2,100 crude oil railcars; and 640 trucks and 1,275 trailers. The Natural Gas Liquids segment engages in the natural gas processing, NGL fractionation, storage, transportation, and terminalling activities. As of December 31, 2021, this segment owned and operated four natural gas processing plants; nine fractionation plants; 28 million barrels of NGL storage capacity; approximately 1,620 miles of active NGL transportation pipelines, as well as an additional 55 miles of pipeline that supports NGL storage facilities; 16 NGL rail terminals and approximately 3,900 NGL rail cars; and approximately 220 trailers. The company was founded in 1981 and is headquartered in Houston, Texas. Plains All American Pipeline, L.P. operates as a subsidiary of Plains GP Holdings, L.P.

Full PAA Calculator →
📬

Get this ICE vs PAA comparison by email

Save your analysis + weekly dividend insights. Free forever.

More comparisons

ICE vs SCHDICE vs JEPIICE vs OICE vs KOICE vs MAIN

⚠️ Educational purposes only. Not financial advice. Congressional trades sourced from SEC STOCK Act filings via FMP. Past performance does not guarantee future results.