Home › Yield Trap & NAV Erosion Calculator
Does a 60% option yield actually beat a 3% dividend grower once you subtract share-price decay (NAV erosion) and 24%–37% ordinary income taxes? Run the side-by-side math below.
Notice how MSTY pays higher headline cash distributions, but a -18%/yr NAV share-price decay and 24% ordinary tax rate erode principal — which is why blending 80–90% core dividend growers (SCHD) with at most 10–20% option income protects your capital.
Covered-call and synthetic option ETFs cap their upside when the underlying stock rallies, while still participating in downside drops — and they pay out huge monthly option premiums. Over time, if distributions exceed total return, the fund's Net Asset Value (share price) steadily decays, reducing future dollar payouts.
In a taxable US brokerage account, option-premium distributions from JEPI, JEPQ, QYLD, and YieldMax ETFs are primarily taxed as ordinary income (up to 24%–37%) or return of capital, whereas SCHD's dividends are ~100% Qualified dividends taxed at 0% or 15% for most households.
Most income investors cap covered-call and synthetic option ETFs at 10% to 20% of their portfolio (ideally inside a tax-sheltered Roth IRA) to boost monthly cash flow while keeping 80%+ in durable dividend-growing equities and REITs.