Home › Yield Trap & NAV Erosion Calculator

⚖️ High Yield vs Total Return · NAV Erosion & Tax Simulator

Yield Trap & NAV Erosion Calculator (MSTY, JEPI & QYLD vs SCHD)

Does a 60% option yield actually beat a 3% dividend grower once you subtract share-price decay (NAV erosion) and 24%–37% ordinary income taxes? Run the side-by-side math below.

🔥 High-Yield / Covered-Call Contender
True Net Wealth After 5 Years (MSTY)
$23,806
Ending Share Value (NAV): $3,707 (-$6,293)
Cash Dividends Collected (After Tax): +$20,098
IRS Taxes Paid (24% Ordinary): −$6,347
Year 5 Annual Income: $2,636/yr
🛡️ Dividend Growth & Quality Anchor
True Net Wealth After 5 Years (SCHD)
$15,566
Ending Share Value (NAV): $13,701 (+$3,701)
Cash Dividends Collected (After Tax): +$1,865
IRS Taxes Paid (15% Qualified): −$329
Year 5 Annual Income: $457/yr
⚖️ 5-Year Reality Check Result
MSTY wins by $8,240 in net after-tax wealth ($23,806 vs $15,566)

Notice how MSTY pays higher headline cash distributions, but a -18%/yr NAV share-price decay and 24% ordinary tax rate erode principal — which is why blending 80–90% core dividend growers (SCHD) with at most 10–20% option income protects your capital.

📊 Test an 80/20 Blend in Portfolio Tracker →

Yield Traps & NAV Erosion — Frequently Asked Questions

What is NAV erosion in high-yield covered-call ETFs like MSTY, CONY, and QYLD?

Covered-call and synthetic option ETFs cap their upside when the underlying stock rallies, while still participating in downside drops — and they pay out huge monthly option premiums. Over time, if distributions exceed total return, the fund's Net Asset Value (share price) steadily decays, reducing future dollar payouts.

How are JEPI, JEPQ, and YieldMax distributions taxed compared to SCHD?

In a taxable US brokerage account, option-premium distributions from JEPI, JEPQ, QYLD, and YieldMax ETFs are primarily taxed as ordinary income (up to 24%–37%) or return of capital, whereas SCHD's dividends are ~100% Qualified dividends taxed at 0% or 15% for most households.

How much of my portfolio should be in ultra-high-yield ETFs?

Most income investors cap covered-call and synthetic option ETFs at 10% to 20% of their portfolio (ideally inside a tax-sheltered Roth IRA) to boost monthly cash flow while keeping 80%+ in durable dividend-growing equities and REITs.

● Updated November 22, 2026
✍️
Created by
Founder & Lead Analyst
🔍
Reviewed for accuracy
DividendFlow Research
Editorial & data team
🏛️
Based on
FMP API + SEC EDGAR
Live data, verified daily
Helpful?
📚 For educational purposes only. Not financial advice. Data sourced from Financial Modeling Prep (FMP) and SEC EDGAR. Results are estimates — actual returns will vary. Full disclaimer →